No rubrics. All love.


Feminizing Nature in Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein

December 10, 2024


In Mary Shelley’s Frankenstein, nature is personified as a metaphorical embodiment of femininity. Victor Frankenstein is a scientist obsessed with dominating nature for his benefit. Once he wins the game of nature vs. man by unnaturally creating his “monster”, Victor watches as the monster represents the consequences of unchecked male dominance. Shelley feminizes nature to show how women are undervalued by the system of gender. By emphasizing and critiquing this system, Shelley presents a new definition of femininity based on the innate power women hold, therefore shifting from the perception that women are meant to be subjugated.

Throughout Frankenstein, Mary Shelley portrays nature as the personification of autonomous femininity to emphasize why Victor has such a strained relationship with nature throughout the novel. While attending university, a young Victor studies a lineage of male scientists who have all shared fantasies about the mystery that is nature: “The ancient teachers of this science… penetrate into the recesses of nature, and show how she works in her hiding places…they have acquired new, and almost unlimited powers; they can command the thunders of heaven, mimic the earthquake, and even mock the invisible world with its own shadows” (52). Victor learns from his professors about the godlike“powers” that these scientists have acquired as a result of “penetrating” nature. This rhetoric used by Victor is masculine and when nature is feminized with “she” pronouns, it is clear that within this male space (university), masculinity is defined by the oppression of women. The personification of nature suggests that women who use their femininity to embrace their natural “powers” can dominate men and therefore pose a threat to patriarchal societies. For men, these “almost unlimited powers”, as obtained by the perversion of nature, symbolize social status and acclaim. When nature is feminized and given power, Shelley’s use of this spiritual language communicates that men are fearful of women. This fear causes men to use gender as a means of achieving their definition of power. The scientific field is a space in the novel where gender is taught and reinforced to Victor. His ardent desire to involve himself in science is exemplified when he retells his purpose in studying alchemy: “A new species would bless me as its creator and source; many happy and excellent natures would owe their being to me” (57). Victor believes that to leave a legacy, he must become a god. This desire is rooted in the teachings of science by his professors as a way to achieve a peak model of masculinity. His wish for a new species of “natures” to bless him for their creation points to his desire to eliminate the only power women hold in society: the female ability to create life.

Mary Shelley writes Elizabeth from Victor’s perspective as an extension of and a support system for Victor to emphasize his inability to see women as equal to men. Elizabeth is characterized as the symbol of femininity without autonomy, as communicated by Victor's objectification of her. Upon her introduction in the novel, Elizabeth is regarded by Victor as a beautiful mystical being without any personality: “Her hair was the brightest living gold…seemed to set a crown of distinction on her head…her blue eyes cloudless, and her lips and the molding of her face so expressive of sensibility and sweetness, that none could behold her without looking on her as of a distinct species, a being heaven-sent…” 42. As a child, Elizabeth is presented here as the symbol of “sensibility and sweetness”, thus suggesting that she has these qualities innately built in her. Shelley’s portrayal of Victor’s objectification of Elizabeth stresses how society accepts the representation of women as things to be used by men in society. Shelly brings to light that this representation is not concrete because Victor cannot properly conceive of Elizabeth as a multifaceted individual. Shelley’s portrayal of Elizabeth is a mockery of how men view women as extensions of themselves, to be molded into whatever role they see fit. Victor views Elizabeth in this manner and it is made apparent by the language he uses when describing her state of being after their mother dies. Just before Victor goes off to University, Caroline Beaufort dies, leaving Elizabeth as the only woman in his life. During this time, Victor speaks highly of Elizabeth, saying, “she indeedveiled her grief and… she looks steadily on life and assumed its duties with courage… She devoted herself to those whom she had been taught to call her uncle and cousins…” (49). Victor speaks of Elizabeth in an honorable manner for having taken immediate agency to care for the needs of her adoptive family. He praises her for having learned her position in the family, saying that she “had been taught” to refer to them as “uncle and cousins”. The significance of this language is that Elizabeth is adopted into the Frankenstein family therefore she should be considered a sister to Victor and a daughter to Alphonse Frankenstein. Instead, the family gives her a role to fulfill as an extended family member or“cousin”. Due to this indefinite role assignment, Elizabeth is allowed to become a cousin, a mother, a fiance and, technically speaking, a sister all within the scope of the novel. When analyzing Vicor’s portrayal of Elizabeth, it is clear that he views her ability to mold into all of these different roles as commemorable. This perspective shows how he views Elizabeth as only deserving of respect because she fulfills his perception of femininity. Shelley incorporates this perspective as the framework for the novel to emphasize that this model of femininity must be eradicated as it prevents men from crediting women for their full potential.

Victor’s egocentric creation becomes a “monster” because it is the product of Victor’s complete suppression of feminine power. Victor damns his creature to the confines of masculinity, thus rendering it incapable of experiencing the joys of nature. When the monster recollects his journey to reuniting with Victor he describes some of his first memories as if he were a child who grew up in the woods: “I was delighted when I first discovered that a pleasant sound…from the throats of little winged animals…sometimes I tried to imitate the pleasant songs of the birds, but was unable. Sometimes I wished to express my sensations…but the uncouth and inarticulate sounds which broke from me frightened me into silence again” (96). Here, the monster is written as an innocent creature that experiences joy when he allows nature to provide him with peace whereas he experiences an upset when he is reminded of his nature. The monster’s “uncouth sounds” are juxtaposed with the “pleasant sound” of the birds here as the monster is learning that he is not of nature because he does not resemble them. A gendered reading of this introduction suggests that the “birds” are feminized to depict the softness of women whereas the monster is masculinized to represent the toughness of men. Shelley presents this contradiction as the monster’s main internal conflict to communicate how men view themselves as the opposite of women, therefore they view themselves as inherently ugly creatures incapable of beholding or creating beauty. The gendering of the monster causes his internal struggle between his internal desires and his fate. “Increase of knowledge only discovered to me more clearly what a wretched outcast I was. I cherished hope.. but it vanished when I beheld my person reflected in water…”(117). The monster battles with being born in a body that does not suit his life purpose. He feels like “a wretched outcast” amongst nature because he cannot partake in its beauty. It is because he is the product or son of a man who could not live harmoniously with nature, the monster is destined to develop the same relationship. It is also because he has become thrust with the knowledge that he finds himself unable to live in his fantasy any longer. This gendered space of knowledge is referenced by Shelley when describing the monster’s descent into madness.

Furthermore, because the monster is not completely human and is instead a “miserable, unhappy wretch” (109), he becomes the hypermasculine, monstrous being that embodies what Shelley suggests are the darkest elements of a man’s nature. In Johanna Smith’s article, “ ‘Cooped Up’ with ‘Sad Trash’: Domesticity and the Sciences in Frankenstein”, she writes that “ the creature destroys precisely those realms of the domestic most closely associated with conventional femininity.” Smith then goes on to list the monster’s victims including “young William living at home under Elizabeth’s care” and “Henry (Clerval), the paradigm of masculine and feminine traits in harmony” to argue that “as Victor’smurderous ‘spirit’, the monster reveals the dark side of the Frankenstein family’s oppressive domesticity” (386). Although this argument is striking, the monster yearns for a connection with femininity and when he is repeatedly declined, he further retreats into his violent, masculine nature thus suggesting that domesticity is not oppressive but rather masculinity is. According to Anne K. Mellor in her article, “Frankenstein, Gender, and Mother Nature”, “By stealing the female's control over natural reproduction, Victor has eliminated the female's primary biological function and a source of cultural power. Indeed, as a male scientist who creates a male creature, Victor eliminates the biological necessity for females all. One of the deepest horrors of this novel is his implicit goal of creating a society for men only” (3). Mellor states that Victor’s desire for a completely male-dominated society is the very thing that creates the horrific nature of the novel. The monster embodies this horror physically and the further he indulges in the destruction of all the feminine elements of the novel's world (“young William” and “Henry”), the further he internalizes the oppression of his gendered qualities. Moreover, even though the monster does not physically appear as a son of nature, he is still allowed to be replenished by its peacefulness, thus suggesting that the world of nature is forgiving whereas the world of man is merciless. Shelley’s complex use of a feminized nature reveals how the monster’s life represents the internal struggles men go through while actively suppressing their femininity.

To conclude, Mary Shelley feminizes nature to create a new perception of femininity that allows women to find power in the innate capabilities that they are often undervalued for. Moreover, Victor’s negative relationship with nature causes the abomination that is the monster to become both his worst enemy and the enemy of all things feminine. Shelley’s portrayal of femininity in this novel is reduced to a simple commentary on female representation during the 19th century. Her complex writing of gender dynamics in the novel allows for conversations around the consequences of men repressing their femininity. The importance of defining one's identity outside of society's expectations is stressed dramatically in the novel as Victor’s complete submission to his gender prevents him from enjoying life, leading to his early demise. Frankenstein allows readers to deconstruct and reconstruct the teachings of gender in their own lives to make it work for their identity.





Shelley, Mary. Frankenstein: “Frankenstein: A Case Study in Contemporary Criticism” Edited by Johanna M. Smith, Bedford/St. Martin's, 2015.

Smith, Johanna M. "‘Cooped Up’ with ‘Sad Trash’: Domesticity and the Sciences in Frankenstein." Frankenstein: A Case Study in Contemporary Criticism, edited by Johanna M. Smith, Bedford/St. Martin's, 2015

Mellor, A. K. (2018). Frankenstein, Gender, and Mother Nature. Frankenbook. Retrieved from https://www.frankenbook.org/pub/frankenstein-gender-mother-nature


Leave a Reply